The UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology and the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade released an independent report on 4 November 2026. It looks at how research and development spending is appraised. In December 2025 DSIT asked an SQW-led consortium to collect evidence on this subject. The work is set out in two documents.
The International case studies paper, available as a PDF of 70 pages, describes how other countries appraise R&D investments. A second document, Strengthening Value for Money assessments for R&D policies, proposes a possible value for money method for R&D policy. The framework covers monetised figures, quantified measures and qualitative findings in business cases, aiming at a balanced judgement on the value for money of R&D proposals.
The research was meant to inform DSIT's response to Recommendation 4 from the Lord Willetts Review, which covered how DSIT approves business cases. DSIT has since been disbanded, and this workstream now sits within the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade. BIST is the short name used for that department. That department may wish to consider this framework when it develops supplementary guidance.
Key facts
- The report was published on 4 November 2026 by DSIT and the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade.
- The International case studies PDF is 1000 KB and runs to 70 pages.
- The Strengthening Value for Money document is a 701 KB PDF of 22 pages.
- An SQW-led consortium, brought in by DSIT in December 2025, gathered the evidence.
- DSIT has since been disbanded, and its workstream sits with BIST.
Why it matters
The suggested framework may be considered by the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade when it develops supplementary guidance. It is aimed at business cases and at reaching a balanced judgement on the value for money of R&D proposals. Both documents are available in HTML and PDF, and an accessible format can be requested by email.




